• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
  • Se Habla Español
  • Contact
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
cropped mountain association logo with copyright.png

Mountain Association

Building a New Economy, Together.

    • Access expertise to grow your business or organization.

      Apply for Support

    • Start Here
      • Learn About Support
      • Apply to Work with a Consultant
      • Success Stories
    • Resources
      • Tools & Templates
      • SPARK Nonprofit Collaborative
      • Client Login
    • Expand your impact with our flexible loans.

      Talk to Us About a Loan

    • Start Here
      • Learn About Loans
      • Start the Application Process
      • Success Stories
    • Resources
      • FAQs
      • Disaster Recovery Loans
      • CrowdMatch Loans
    • We can help you save money.

      Apply for an Energy Assessment

    • Start Here
      • Learn About Our Energy Program
      • Apply for a Free Energy Savings Assessment
      • Success Stories
    • Resources
      • FAQs
      • Solar Support
      • Energy Savings Microloan
    • Start something in your community.

      How We Can Help

    • Start Here
      • How We Support Communities
      • Success Stories
    • Hazard, KY
      • 479 Main Street Project
      • Long-Term Work
    • We can help tell your story.

      Read Our Stories

    • Blog
      • Read Stories
      • Newsletter | Social Media
    • Communications
      • Press & Media
      • EKY Influencer & Media Network
    • Building a new economy, together.

      (859) 986-2373

      info@mtassociation.org

      Sign Me Up for News

    • About Us
      • What We Do
      • A New Economy
        • How It’s Working
    • Our People
      • Team
      • Board of Directors
      • Careers
    • Impact
      • Our History
      • By the Numbers
      • Publications
  • (859) 986-2373

    info@mtassociation.org

     

    Building a new economy, together.
You are here: Home / Uncategorized / Daily Yonder: How’re You ‘Being,’ Rural?…Not So Well

Uncategorized

Daily Yonder: How’re You ‘Being,’ Rural?…Not So Well

March 9, 2011

Share:

Julie Ardery and Bill Bishop at Daily Yonder have a thought-provoking piece on the results of Gallup's 'well-being' survey.  We have talked about this survey here before, but Ardery and Bishop highlight new points about the lack of wellness, as measured by various self-reported health, happiness, economic prosperity and optimism about the future, across Appalachia culminating in Kentucky's 5th Congressional districted.  Represented by Hal Rogers since 1981, and one of the biggest coal producing districts in the region.  What is really interesting though is the comparisons between Wyoming–the #1 coal producing region in the country — and Kentucky's 5th district.  Ardery and Bishop write "Wyoming scores very high on reports of physical and emotional well-being, as well as work quality and life prospects; alson, only 3% of Wyoming residents failed to complete the ninth grade (in comparison with 22% of 5th District Kentuckians)."  What is Wyoming doing differently, and what can we learn from Wyoming to put in place here in Appalachia?

A survey of quality of life finds that wellness doesn't extend from sea to shining sea. With few exceptions, the most-rural parts of the nation rank lowest in well-being.

By Julie Ardery and Bill Bishop
well being map

In a year-long national study, residents in most of the nation's 124 most-rural congressional districts reported poor quality of life.

An international health business, the Gallup survey organization, and an association of insurance companies joined forces on a major national survey of life-styles, health, and work – measuring that elusive phenomenon “well being.” Their respondents in Hawaii described the highest levels of well being, West Virginians the lowest.

The Daily Yonder, taking a closer look at the survey results, finds that of the nation’s 435 congressional districts, Kentucky’s fifth district — the most rural in the U.S. — also scored at the very bottom in terms of its well-being. Those in Kentucky’s fifth district reported the poorest physical and emotional health in the nation, and also scored lowest on a more general measure of “life evaluation” – assessing both current living conditions and prospects for the near future.

Looking at all 435 congressional districts, we found the most-rural U.S. districts (with populations at least 1/3 rural) clustered at the bottom of the “well-being” rankings. Only four of the nation’s 125 most rural congressional districts scored in the top 1/5th: Minnesota’s 6th District, Tennessee’s 7th, Alabama’s 6th, and Wyoming (the entire state of Wyoming comprises one congressional district).

hal rogers in somersetU.S. Congressman Hal RogersHal Rogers (shown here at a recylcing center in Somerset) represents Kentucky's 5th District, the most rural congressional district in the U.S. Residents of his district also ranked lowest in the nation in a survey of "well-being."But 37 of these “most rural” districts ranked in the lowest fifth on the well-being index.  They’re found in a swath through Appalachia, from western Pennsylvania through north Alabama, and along the southern stretch of the Mississippi River. Other rural districts that ranked low in their reports of well-being are in the eastern Carolinas, the Florida panhandle, and northern Michigan. 

The Gallup-Healthways Well-Being Index is compiled from phone interviews with 355,344 people across the nation. A random 1000 people were questioned daily throughout 2008 about six core topics: Basic Access to food, safety, shelter, and health care; Emotional Health; Physical Health; Healthy Behaviors; Work Environment; and Life Evaluation – an assessment of one’s current situation and outlook on the future, five years hence.

In general, respondents in the West reported more healthy behaviors, and those in the upper Midwest scored high on their reports of emotional health. Texans and those in the Rocky Mountain states expressed generally more positive levels of work satisfaction. And in Utah there seems unanimity that life’s good and the future will be even better. Find much more information from the survey on the American Health Insurance Plans’ website, found here.  

As one would expect, there’s a lot of overlap between districts that are poor and those reporting low levels of well-being. After Kentucky’s mountainous Fifth District, the next lowest ranking area is New York ultra-urban 16th, located in the Bronx, with 42% of residents below the poverty line.

less than 9th grade educationAHIPThe survey also asked respondents about their income and education. The districts with highest percentages of people who had not completed the 9th grade (shown in green) match the Yonder map's most-rural districts with very low well-being. (The AHIP map shows all counties, not just the most rural.)According to America's Health Insurance Plans’ own graphics, the rural counties with very low scores of well-being are also those with very low rates of educational attainment. The green districts on the AHIP map are those where the highest numbers of residents have not completed 9th grade. This pattern nearly matches Yonder’s map of most rural counties in the lowest fifth on the well-being measure. (Similarly, in New York's 16th district — too small geographically to spot on this map — 22% of residents have not completed 9th grade.) 

So what about those very rural anomalies with super “quality of life”? Wyoming scores very high on reports of physical and emotional well-being, as well as work quality and life prospects; also, only 3% of Wyoming residents failed to complete the ninth grade (in comparision with 22% of 5th District Kentuckians).

Michele BachmannCongresswoman Michele BachmannMichele Bachmann, shown here touring Shelburne National Wildlife Area, represents Minnesota's 6th district, one of only four very rural congressional districts that scored in the top fifth on the well-being index.The other three well-est rural counties, where more than a third of residents are rural, are located in well-to-do exurbs of large cities: surrounding Birmingham, west of Minneapolis, and between Memphis and Nashville. (Tennessee’s 7th, shaped like a windblown palm tree, is a gerrymandered district, and the wealthiest in the state).

Despite the tremendous resources, financial and statistical, that went into this project, it may not come as a shock that people in Appalachia and the Mississippi Delta aren't out snowboarding or visiting the dentist, or than residents of the Rust Belt doubt that conditions in their communities will look a lot better five years from now. Still, a study this extensive and rigorous makes it possible to see "well-being" more closely — regional inequality, also: living day-to-day with clean or dirty water, work or idleness, songbirds or sirens, a clear head or an aching one.

Recent Posts

renew appalachia martin County reclaim mine abandoned land

Community Development

Rewilding 7,000 Acres of Eastern Kentucky’s Mined Land

In the coalfields of Martin County in Eastern Kentucky, where mining once shaped both the land and the economy, a new initiative is getting off the ... Read This Post

Churches in EAstern Kentucky can save big on energy.

Energy

Energy Savings Guide for Churches

We recently worked with several churches on finding ways to save on their bills. We developed this guide to walk them through making decisions around ... Read This Post

houses eastern kentucky energy bills efficiency appalachia 1

Energy

Why Cutting LIHEAP Is a Deadly Blow to Eastern Kentucky

By any measure, the economy of Eastern Kentucky and the wider Appalachian region is struggling. The collapse of the coal industry, the opioid crisis, ... Read This Post

Footer

cropped mountain association logo with copyright.png

Established in 1976. Prior to 2020, we were known as the Mountain Association for Community Economic Development (MACED).

Donate Now 1

Get the Newsletter

Sign Up Now

  • Programs
    • Business Support
    • Lending
    • Energy
    • Communities
    • Stories
  • About
    • What We Do
    • A New Economy
    • Team
    • Our History
    • By the Numbers
  • More
    • Donate
    • Careers
    • Board of Directors
    • Publications
    • Sponsorships

BEREA
(859) 986-2373
433 Chestnut Street
Berea, KY 40403

Meetings by appointment only

info@mtassociation.org

We are happy to make any accommodation
to better serve you. We have an on-staff
Spanish interpreter, and provide
additional free language/
interpretation services as needed.

If hearing or speech impaired,
please dial 7-1-1 for relay
services prior to calling.

HAZARD
(606) 439-0170
420 Main St
Hazard, KY 41701

PRESTONSBURG
(606) 264-5910
268 E Friend St, Ste 101
Prestonsburg, KY 41653

Copyright © 2025 Mountain Association | Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions | Non-profit Disclosures

made by P&P
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.Ok